When did a human become the luxury option?
I've been a designer for over 25 years, and I never expected to see the day when "made by a person" became a selling point. But here we are, and I have to admit, I rather love it.
Not long ago, having a logo, a website and a set of matching social graphics was enough to look established. Now anyone can produce all three before their tea goes cold. AI can give you a perfectly presentable brand in an afternoon, and for plenty of businesses that's a sensible place to start.
But something interesting happens when everyone has access to the same tools. Presentable stops being impressive. When polished is free, polished stops meaning anything.
So what do people notice instead? The things that can't be prompted.
They notice a brand that sounds like the person who runs it. They notice the colour chosen because it's the exact green of the founder's grandmother's kitchen door, not because it tested well. They notice when the website, the proposal and the thank-you card all feel like they came from the same place, because someone was paying attention the whole way through.
That's what a human brings. Not the making, which has never been the hard part, but the noticing. The awkward question in the first conversation that changes the whole direction. The moment I say, "I know you asked for that, but I don't think it's right for you, and here's why." The judgement to leave something out.
It reminds me of what happened to other crafts. We can all buy a flat-pack wardrobe, and yet a fitted one made by a joiner who came to measure the room has never been more prized. Machines didn't kill the handmade. They made it mean something.
When did a human become the luxury option?
I've been a designer for over 25 years, and I never expected to see the day when "made by a person" became a selling point. But here we are, and I have to admit, I rather love it.
For most of my career, nobody asked whether a human had designed something. Of course one had. It would have been like asking a baker whether they'd used an oven. Now it's a genuine question, and the answer has started to carry weight.
Everyone can look presentable now
Not long ago, having a logo, a website and a set of matching social graphics was enough to look established. It took time, money and usually a designer, so simply having those things told people you were serious.
Now anyone can produce all three before their tea goes cold. AI will give you a perfectly presentable brand in an afternoon, and for plenty of businesses that's a sensible place to start. If you're testing an idea or just getting going, I'd never tell you otherwise.
But something interesting happens when everyone has access to the same tools. Presentable stops being impressive. When polished is free, polished stops meaning anything. And when thousands of businesses are all drawing from the same well, they start to look and sound remarkably alike. Lovely, tidy and oddly forgettable.
What people notice instead
So what stands out when everything looks good? The things that can't be prompted.
People notice a brand that sounds like the person who runs it. They notice the colour chosen because it's the exact green of the founder's grandmother's kitchen door, not because it tested well. They notice when the website, the proposal and the thank-you card all feel like they came from the same place, because someone was paying attention the whole way through.
They might not be able to tell you why one brand feels right and another feels hollow. But they feel it, and they trust the one that feels like somebody cared.
The making was never the hard part
Here's something designers don't always admit: producing the logo has never been the difficult bit. The difficult bit is knowing which logo is right, and why, and what to leave out.
That comes from noticing. The slightly awkward question in the first conversation that changes the whole direction. The throwaway remark a founder makes about why they started, which turns out to be the heart of the whole brand. The moment I say, "I know you asked for that, but I don't think it's right for you, and here's why."
AI will give you exactly what you ask for. A good designer will sometimes give you something you didn't know to ask for, and occasionally talk you out of the thing you did.
We've seen this before
None of this is new, really. We can all buy a flat-pack wardrobe, and yet a fitted one made by a joiner who came to measure the room has never been more prized. We can all buy a sliced white loaf, and still there's a queue outside the bakery on a Saturday morning. A printed card costs pennies, which is exactly why a handwritten one means so much.
Machines didn't kill the handmade. They made it mean something. The more that can be produced instantly, the more we value the things that clearly took thought, time and a person who gave a monkey's.
Design is going the same way, and I think that's good news for everyone.
Where AI fits in my studio
I should be clear that I'm not against AI. It's a brilliant tool and I use it. It helps with research, speeds up the dull bits and leaves more room for the thinking, which is the part clients are really paying for.
But a tool can't sit across the table from you and work out what you're really trying to say. It can't spot that your business has quietly become something bigger than your brand suggests. It can't care whether you do well.
I can. And apparently that now makes me a luxury.
Luxury doesn't mean extravagant
I'll take the label, but I want to be careful with it. Luxury here doesn't mean flashy or indulgent. It means considered. It means being listened to properly, having someone think hard about your business in particular, and ending up with something that could only ever be yours.
It also means consistency over time. A brand isn't finished the day the logo is signed off. It lives in every email, every leaflet, every post, and it needs someone who knows it well enough to keep it feeling like itself. Having a person who understands your brand and looks after it, month after month, is perhaps the greatest luxury of all.
The businesses I work with are brilliant at what they do. They deserve more than the average of everything that already exists.
If that sounds like what your business needs for its next chapter, tell me about your project. I'd love to hear your story.
Here's to your next chapter,
Kirsty
I can. And apparently that now makes me a luxury.
I'll take it. Because the businesses I work with are brilliant at what they do, and they deserve more than the average of everything that already exists. They deserve a brand that could only ever be theirs.
If that sounds like what your business needs for its next chapter, tell me about your project. I'd love to hear your story.
Here's to your next chapter,
Kirsty




Comments